Mark Spoils: The Great 30-Day Who MEME!!!!

Thursday, March 3, 2011

The Great 30-Day Who MEME!!!! - Day Fifteen

What is your favorite Rose moment?

When Rose reappears during 'The Stolen Earth' all you can really say is "FUCK YEAH, Rose Tyler!" I mean what's not to love? It's Rose, she has a giant fucking gun, and she's here to kick ass and take names. Of course, it doesn't really last long, but for that moment of shining glory I loved Rose more than I have ever loved her before.

So what about you? What's your favorite scene or moment featuring Rose?

Tomorrow: Favorite Martha moment!

Comments (35)

Logging you in...

Dashboard | Edit profile | Logout

Logged in as

+10 Vote up Vote down

flamingpie 89p · 734 weeks ago

Oh man Rose in the Stolen Earth is AWESOME but I gotta go for something else I'm afraid.

This. This without a doubt.

I have a lot of love for Rose. I understand perfectly why a lot of people don't. But this scene right here? This is exactly why I love her so much.

She isn't perfect. She's far from it. She can be intensely childish and selfish. But none of that stops her from being a good person. Selfish as she can be sometimes, she always does what she thinks is right, and she stands by her convictions. She may be wrong sometimes, but who isn't? She gets shit done, and she develops from a hopeless girl into a totally badass defender of the earth. I see this scene as the first little sign of that huge change. The situation back with the Doctor is dire, and she could just do what he said, leave the TARDIS there and move on. Far in the future as it is, it would never effect her or her family. But just forgetting about it would be WRONG, and she won't abide by that. And says so in one of my favorite speeches from Who, period. I just... love this scene.

Report

+6 Vote up Vote down

Medli 141p · 734 weeks ago

I'm going to go with "all of Turn Left" because I really liked her there. I can't even explain why, maybe I just like how she interacts with Donna.

Close second would be the "Do you like my gun?" bit from Stolen Earth, and shooting out the rocket's viewscreen in Satan Pit.

Report

3 replies · active 734 weeks ago

+8 Vote up Vote down

Albion19 84p · 734 weeks ago

Hmm she's not my favourite but I love that moment in s1 where she gives the impassioned speech in the cafe about making a stand etc was fantastic.

Report

+11 Vote up Vote down

psycicflower 114p · 734 weeks ago

I think I'm going to go for the original FUCK YEAH ROSE! moment way back in series 1 episode 1:
'I've got no A-Levels, no job, no future... but I tell ya what I have got - Jericho Street Junior School - Under Sevens Gymnastic Team - I got the Bronze!'
It really shows Rose taking charge and how she's not going to let anything stop her, regardless of what anyone else tells her about her life or background.

Report

1 reply · active 734 weeks ago

+6 Vote up Vote down

fantasylover12001 · 734 weeks ago

Oh yeah, Stolen Earth two parter hands down is when Rose was at her best. I particularly love the part where she freaks out the looters and goes "Hi guys. Do you like my gun?"

Report

+7 Vote up Vote down

echinodermata 118p · 734 weeks ago

TARDIS!Rose (Rose!TARDIS?). She IS Bad Wolf, you guys!

"I looked into the TARDIS. And the TARDIS looked into me...I am the Bad Wolf. I create myself. I take the words; I scatter them in time and space...You are tiny. I can see the whole of time and space - every single atom of your existence, and I divide them. Everything must come to dust; all things. Everything dies. The Time War ends...I can see everything. All that is, all that was, all that ever could be."

This was easily my favorite of RTD's finales, and it's largely because of this scene.

Report

16 replies · active 734 weeks ago

+5 Vote up Vote down

Kaybee42 91p · 734 weeks ago

Series 6 spoilers, not too major, only referring to actors who may be a surprise.
...
Tweet from James Corden:
"Finished League of their own last night.Now i'm in Cardiff for the first day on Dr Who.We're filming all night till 8am!!! x"
How exciting is that! It's very late in the filming isn't it? do you think they are to do with the second half or the series? or just the first half?

Report

+3 Vote up Vote down

hassibah 113p · 734 weeks ago

I like Rose best in the first half of season 1. If I had to go with just one thing she did, prolly the talking to she gave 9 at the end of Dalek. I like her a lot in Father's Day too but that's not really a badass day for her.

Turn Left is also a really good answer, but it's not quite mine.

Report

+3 Vote up Vote down

mkjcaylor 87p · 734 weeks ago

I am sadly not a very big fan of her in Turn Left, which is I guess sadly why I'm not a huge fan of the episode. She's so different from the Rose that I love that I almost see her as someone else. She also looks so flipping different, gawd.

My favorite Rose moment:

Rose as she's being leader to everyone on the Impossible Planet after the Doctor goes down into the pit. I think that is the pinnacle of Rose after she has matured and changed and is now capable of taking on scary situations alone.

(I want to pick Cassandra/Rose or TARDIS/Rose but they aren't actually all Rose so I'm not. Cassandra/Rose is some of my favorite Billie Piper acting.)

Report

1 reply · active 734 weeks ago

+4 Vote up Vote down

Dragon Elexus 124p · 734 weeks ago

Favourite Rose moments? Well, I agree that when she shows up in the Stolen Earth with that gun, she's pretty much BAMF. But that's not my favourite.

Runner up: The times in Idiot's Lantern when she's teasing the father. I don't know why. Partly its because of how witty she's being ("Shame on you, hanging the union jack upside down!"), but also that she has this wicked, mischevious look on her face, like a little imp. Its not a big moment, but I love it.

Winner: When she tries to communicate to the dalek, in Dalek. This is an alien creature, not even vaguely resembling human life, but Rose doesn't hesitate to try and communicate with it and save its life. And yes, we know that its an alien death machine that will kill everything - sheM doesn't. And to me, it highlights her wilingness to help and open mindedness that she has, even with her faults.

Report

+3 Vote up Vote down

Openattheclose 99p · 734 weeks ago

When she defends Jackie to Elton in "Love and Monsters."

She comes off a bit hypocritical, but I still love her for dropping everything and coming to stop the meanie that was using her Mum. Not that Elton was really a meanie, but she didn't know that.

Report

+1 Vote up Vote down

Yinz Lia 64p · 376 weeks ago

Hiya, I’m really glad I have found this info. Nowadays bloggers publish only about gossip and web stuff and this is actually frustrating. A good site with interesting content, this is what I need. Thanks for making this site, and I will be visiting again. Do you do newsletters by email?
dewa poker
raja poker
togel online

Report